• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

High Tide Restaurant: A Coastal Gem in Key Largo

High Tide Restaurant, located at 99411 Overseas Hwy in Key Largo, Florida, is a charming dining spot renowned for its friendly atmosphere and attentive service. Guests consistently rave about the delicious, flavorful dishes, such as the popular Key Lime Fish Sandwich and grilled Mahi Mahi. Reviewers highlight the personable staff, epitomized by waitresses who ensure that coffee and water glasses are never empty. The setting is pleasantly cozy, making it ideal for a casual meal with family or friends. With great prices and generous portions, High Tide has quickly become a local favorite and a must-visit for travelers.

Photos & Gallery

High Tide Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Matthew Rutter
Matthew Rutter

What a great place! Really great service, friendly and kind, never let my coffee get below half full without offering to refill which was good, same with the water. The food was so good and great price too. Will be coming back & highly recommend!!

Sukhmani Kocher
Sukhmani Kocher

Daisy was our waitress and the restaurant was small but cute! Daisy was so sweet and attentive and the food was amazing, not to mention so accommodating with a custom order request. The food was delicious and came out steaming hot and so flavorful, perfectly cooked. Would absolutely recommend!

fiona deroo
fiona deroo

Had dinner here for the first time yesterday and have to say we were pleasantly surprised. We had the Key Lime Fish Sandwich and the Fish Sandwich, grilled (Mahi Mahi). Both were 5 star ! We were promptly greeted upon entering the restaurant, and the service throughout was fantastic. Loved the pleasant atmosphere, nice and clean, music was not blaring like in many other joints. Our waitress had a lovely sense of humor and was very attentive. We are locals, and this is now one of a new favorite spots for a casual place to grab some good food. Thank you to everyone at High Tide!

Tony Raymond
Tony Raymond

Just a quick stop to grab a bite on the way to Key West. Food was quite tasty. The Key Lime fish sandwich was delish; the key lime was not overpowering as one might expect. The BLT was toasted just right. The only drawback was that there was just not enough slaw! It was yummy, but it came in an itty bitty container - about 3 bites worth. ;) If you get the opportunity to order the slaw, do it. Service was spot on, uber friendly, and they offered to get us drinks to go! Plenty of seating inside and out. Not real busy on a Tuesday...but it could be a happening place on weekends. That said, parking is kinda limited. Still, definitely on the list of faves to eat in Key Largo!

Pete Grahame
Pete Grahame

I think it's been our third time.Eating here.Over the last few years, it has always been Consistently Awesome friendly staff, Great good food & proportions, on top of refills for your coffee ,this place is a 10 !

Michelle Lane
Michelle Lane

Although I can’t say much for the atmosphere as it is just a basic diner looking restaurant. However, the waitresses were very bubbly and did a great job recommending food/drinks. The food was amazing. We had the Drunken Shrimp and the Key Lime Fish sandwich with onion rings. We highly recommend both.

Mariah Nicole
Mariah Nicole

Mom and pop/family feel type of diner and it is amazing. Came in for breakfast today and felt kindness and an extremely welcoming energy from the staff. I didn’t catch the name of our waitresses but we had a couple helping us and they were so sweet and attentive. Service was friendly and fast. The food was very high quality! It was fresh, light, and satisfying. I had the egg whites, tomatoes, turkey sausage and a biscuit and it all came out perfect. My boyfriend ordered the two eggs and two small pancakes and it came with a meat choice (he had turkey sausage) and he added a biscuit as well. The biscuits were a recommendation from our waitress and i’m so glad she did! We loved them. We will definitely be back :)

Location

Welcome to High Tide Restaurant, where culinary delights meet the serene surroundings of Key Largo. Nestled at 99411 Overseas Hwy, this charming eatery blends the essence of Florida's coastal cuisine with a welcoming atmosphere that's bound to make you feel right at home. With its prime location, it's an ideal pit stop for both locals and travelers journeying toward Key West.

The heart of High Tide lies not only in its menu but in the dedication of its staff. Guests rave about the attentive service, with many highlighting how waitstaff like Daisy offer a personal touch, ensuring that your coffee cup never runs dry and that your dining experience is as smooth as the ocean waves outside. This level of care sets a warm tone for the restaurant, making it a favorite for diners seeking both flavor and friendliness.

Now, let's dive into the offerings. High Tide is especially renowned for its Key Lime Fish Sandwich—a culinary masterpiece that balances the zest of key lime with perfectly grilled Mahi Mahi. Local patrons like Fiona have praised its delightful harmony of flavors, and many agree it’s a must-try! Food here is served piping hot, testifying to the kitchen's commitment to quality. The emphasis on fresh, flavorful ingredients shines through every dish, earning High Tide a reputation for deliciousness that keeps guests returning.

Beyond its standout sandwiches, the restaurant fosters a pleasant atmosphere where you can enjoy good food without the distraction of blaring music, making it an excellent choice for a relaxed meal. Couples can savor their dinner while families can gather around, creating memories that linger long after the last bite is taken. And for those who appreciate a touch of humor with their meal, the friendly staff makes each dining experience even more enjoyable—something noted by returning visitors like Pete, who have found a sense of community here.

Overall, High Tide Restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it is a celebration of local flavors, warmth, and camaraderie. Whether you're a local or just passing through, it’s a destination worth stopping at. Don’t forget to try the slaw to complement your meal—the locals recommend it! If you’re in the area, stop by and discover why High Tide is quickly becoming a beloved staple in Key Largo.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Delivery
    • On-site services
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards